The 10 Best Vibrating Dog Collars For Negative Feedback Training

Does your dog never stop barking? Does he keep you up at night? Does she have some bad habits that are very hard to unlearn?

A vibrating dog collar may just be the answer for you. It is a type of training device that provides negative feedback to a dog when it does something wrong.

Vibrating dog collars are touted as safe, humane methods of training.

They provide pain-free and harmless features, unlike spray and shock collars. The most commonly used kind is meant to prevent barking, though it can also be used to stop aggression, bad habits, or wandering.

If you’re interested in trying out a vibrating dog collar for your pet, you need to make sure that you are choosing ones that are effective, safe, and humane.

To help you out, here’s our buying guide for these training devices and our picks for the 10 best vibrating dog collars.

Editors Pick

PetKing Premium No Bark Dog Collar

The Stand Out Vibrating Collar For Most Dog Breeds

The PetKing No Bark Collar is a dog-friendly, Non-Harmful device that has proven popular across many different dog breeds. The price and performance are up there with the best.

Read Full Review

The 10 Best Vibrating Dog Collars Comparison Table

Features To Look Out For

Type

There are a few main kinds of vibrating dog collars designed for anti-bark training. Here are a few of them:

Sound detectors

These collars respond to sound and noise. This may not be the best if you live in a loud environment or close to other dogs.

Vibration detectors

Some collars use prongs or other devices to gently press against a dog’s throat, thereby detecting the vibrations caused by barking.

Remote controlled

If you have the time to keep a watchful eye or a sharp ear out, you can remotely send vibrations to these types of collars whenever you hear your dog bark or see it engaging in bad behaviour.

Fence links

These collars are linked to a complimenting invisible fence, and they send negative feedback to a dog when it crossed the perimeter. Of course, this means it isn’t really always meant for barking. We won’t be talking about any of these today.

Durability

Dogs play, run, and get up to all sorts of mischief, whether they’re wearing a collar or not. A good vibrating dog collar will be able to withstand all sorts of wear and tear while a pooch romps around outside and engages in rough, energetic behaviour.

Size

Most vibrating dog collars are adjustable. But if you have a very large or very small pup, they still may not be able to use the standard one. Make sure the collar you’re choosing is the right fit.

Guarantees

Not all training methods work for all dogs. In the event that your pup is resistant to training through vibrating collars, you’ll want to be able to return the purchased item and receive a refund.

Vibrating Dog Collar Reviews

1. PetKing Premium No Bark Dog Collar

Pros

  • Adjustable size
  • Designed to prevent random triggering
  • Easy to use
  • 30-day satisfaction guarantee

Cons

  • Recommended for use with human supervision
  • May not work on very furry or very thick-coated dogs
  • Poor quality control

The PetKing Premium No Bark Dog Collar is a prong-based collar that works by detecting vibrations from a dog’s throat that indicate barking.

When it detects this, it emits a loud beep. If barking continues, it will commence using vibration as a corrective measure.

This collar fits dogs weighing between 2.7 kg and 55 kg, so it should fit most pups, but those with thick coats may prevent the prongs from properly detecting vibration.

In addition, this collar was made in order to prevent the accidental triggering so commonly associated with vibrating dog collars.

Unfortunately, poor quality control is reported with this product, so you may receive a defective item by accident.

The good news is that a 30-day satisfaction guarantee allows you to easily exchange bad collars for good ones!

It is worth noting, though, that the collar is recommended for use with human supervision, so consider that when deciding.

2. PetMania Dog Bark Collar with Vibration

Pros

  • Adjustable size
  • Adjustable sensitivity
  • 7 levels progressive training
  • Made from strong satin
  • Has reflective straps for better visibility
  • 60-day money-back guarantee

Cons

  • May be set off by the barking of other dogs
  • Vibration is still quite strong on the lowest setting
  • Strap can become loose with some dogs
  • Cannot be left on for more than 6 hours

The PetMania Dog Bark Collar with Vibration is an adjustable collar that fits dogs with neck sizes between 7 and 22 inches.

It can be used for many breeds, not just because of its size but because it has adjustable sensitivity levels.

Plus, 7 training levels allow you to perform progressive training in a humane and safe manner with your pup.

This vibrating dog collar also uses high-frequency sounds in its training, alongside buzzing vibrations.

It is lightweight for better comfort and is made with reflective straps so you can spot your dog easily.

In addition, it is made from a strong and durable satin weaved nylon that withstands rough play and wear.

Do note that this collar uses a prong system that means it can only be worn for a maximum of six hours at a time.

It is also very sensitive and may be set off by the barking of other dogs, and its vibration can be too strong for very small or fragile pups.

The prongs may also allow some dogs to free themselves from the collar if they please.

Regardless, a 60-day money-back guarantee will allow you to test this collar out for yourself to see if your pup faces these problems.

3. Petic Advanced 2in1 Anti Bark Dog Collar

Pros

  • Adjustable size
  • Strong buckle
  • 7 progressive sensitivity levels
  • High-visibility faceplates
  • 30-day money-back guarantee
  • RoHS and CE certified for UK and EU

Cons

  • Not suitable for small dogs
  • Quality control issues
  • Burns through battery quickly

The Petic Advanced 2in1 Anti Bark Dog Collar is fitted with 7 automatically progressing training levels that utilize vibration and loud noise to correct a dog’s barking.

It fits dogs with neck sizes between 17 and 55cm, which, while excluding smaller dogs, means it fits a wide variety of medium and large ones.

Do note that this device uses a unique kind of battery that is hard to find in stores, but also burns through them fairly quickly, so be prepared.

Some quality control issues have also been reported. Still, with that being said, it is safety certified for the EU and UK with RoHS and CE approvals, so it’s hard to go wrong.

On top of all of that, this vibrating dog collar has a 30-day satisfaction guarantee and a no-questions-asked return policy, so there is no risk in purchasing the collar and trying it out!

Other bonus features, like its high-visibility faceplates and very strong buckle, make it even more worth the buy.

4. MASBRILL Anti Bark Collar

Pros

  • Adjustable size
  • Intelligent recognition to stop it from picking up other barks
  • 7 progressive training levels
  • 90-day money-back guarantee

Cons

  • More expensive size must be purchased for larger dogs
  • Vibration is not very strong; collar uses noise more than vibration

The MASBRILL Anti Bark Collar is a collar with 7 progressive training levels.

You can set the default sensitivity or allow the levels to rise the more your dog barks within a minute, making for an easy training experience.

This vibrating dog collar comes in a few different sizes for varying breeds.

It uses prongs to detect barking and emits beeping and vibration when your dog sets it off. On top of that, it uses advanced technology that stops it from picking up the barks of any other canines in the area.

However, strong-willed pups may be able to ignore the weaker-than-average vibration that this collar uses, rendering it ineffectual.

The good news is that you can use the product’s 90-day money-back guarantee to test the item out to see if it will work for your dog, so it’s worth the risk!

5. Premium Paws Advanced Intelligence Anti Bark Dog Collar

Pros

  • Adjustable size
  • 7 progressive sensitivity levels
  • 30-day money-back guarantee
  • Comes with free dog psychology ebook

Cons

  • Maybe set off by the barking of other dogs
  • Extremely strong vibration may be too intense

The Premium Paws Advanced Intelligence Anti Bark Dog Collar uses 7 progressive sensitivity levels in order to train your dog to stop barking.

These are designed to increase intelligently (though you can pre-set it) so as not to be too harsh on your dog.

However, do note that this vibrating dog collar has a very intense vibration, even when you adjust the sensitivity.

More nervous or anxious dogs may react extremely negatively to it as a result, so keep that in mind when purchasing.

Do also note that further sensitivity issues might cause the collar to be set off by other loud noises or other dogs.

With that being said, this device does come with a free ebook on canine psychology and boasts a 30-day money back guarantee.

6. Nakosite PET2433 Best Anti Bark Dog Collar

Pros

  • Adjustable
  • Water-resistant
  • 7 progressive sensitivity levels
  • Comes with free LED dog tag
  • 90-day satisfaction guarantee

Cons

  • Cannot be used for very small dogs
  • Burns through batteries quickly
  • Quality control issues

The Nakosite PET2433 Best Anti Bark Dog Collar is a prong-based collar that detects barks through the skin of a dog’s throat.

It uses 7 progressive training levels to emit the appropriate tone and vibration to correct an incessantly barking dog.

These sensitivities can also be pre-set for individual needs.

This vibrating dog collar is water-resistant and works best for dogs with neck dimensions between 10 and 24 inches. Although this excludes smaller dogs, it great for medium and large ones!

Unfortunately, quality control issues plague this product, so you may need to deal with the hassle of requesting an exchange or refund if your item is defective.

Still, a 90-day satisfaction guarantee makes this risk worth it.

7. TopDog Dog Anti Bark Collar

Pros

  • Adjustable size
  • Adjustable sensitivity
  • Adheres to safety and quality standards
  • 60-day money-back guarantee

Cons

  • No off button, so battery must be manually removed and replaced to conserve it
  • May have sensitivity issues
  • Buckle is loose

The TopDog Dog Anti Bark Collar is a simple dog collar that uses a loud tone and vibrations to train a pup to stop yapping.

It works for all dogs that weigh between 6 and 120 lbs, so it works for almost all breeds.

This vibrating dog collar is known to be effective and has an adjustable sensitivity so you can decide the intensity of the corrective vibration.

At the right settings, it responds to barks but not quiet noises, so your canine companion still has verbal freedom.

Sadly, the buckle on this collar leaves something to be desired and may come loose with rough play.

There are also sensitivity issues that may give a dog confusing mixed messages. An additional hassle comes into play because, without an off button, batteries have to be manually removed and inserted.

However, with a 60-day money-back guarantee, it’s worth giving this device a try.

8. Top-Newest Dog Training Collar

Pros

  • Remote controlled so you determine when it goes off
  • Adjustable size
  • 99 levels of intensity
  • IP67 waterproof
  • Rechargeable
  • Can be purchased in multiples at a discounted price
  • 30-day money-back guarantee

Cons

  • Weak vibration
  • May have charging problems
  • Higher price than average

The Top-Newest Dog Training Collar is a remote-controlled vibrating dog collar that has a whopping 99 levels of intensity for single vibration and continuous vibration.

The remote uses an LCD display that indicates battery percentage and other information, and the collar uses silicone-covered prongs to operate.

Without the need to replace batteries, this collar’s 2 to 3-hour rechargeable nature is a great selling point.

It even enters an automatic sleep mode to conserve battery. However, some charging difficulties may arise that could prevent you from using the device.

In general, its vibrations are also quite weak and therefore may not register on bigger dogs.

With that being said, there’s no denying the benefits of this vibrating dog collar.

It’s usable at long distances, is highly durable and waterproof, and fits all dogs between 10 and 130 lbs.

The 30-day money-back guarantee also means you won’t have to worry about a high-risk purchase, so it’s more than worth a try.

9. Simply Silence Anti Barking Dog Collar

Pros

  • Adjustable
  • Water-resistant
  • 2 different node options to accommodate different sized dogs
  • 7 progressive sensitivity levels
  • Comes with free white LED tag
  • 100% satisfaction guarantee

Cons

  • Higher priced than similar products
  • Cannot be used for very small dogs
  • Burns through batteries quickly

The Simply Silence Anti Barking Dog Collar uses 2 nodes that press against a dog’s throat to detect the feedback from barking.

Two different sets of nodes are available to best suit your dog’s size. Plus, seven sensitivity levels allow you to specifically choose the best settings for your pup.

This vibrating dog collar is water-resistant and corrects behaviour through a mix of noise and vibration.

It is easy to use and fits dogs with neck sizes measuring between 10 and 22 inches, though this means it is not suitable for smaller pooches.

Unfortunately, this device does use a lot of power, so be prepared to change batteries often.

You should also note that this device is a little more expensive than other products in the market, but with that higher price tag comes a free LED tag for night walks, better features, and a 100% satisfaction guarantee, so we say it’s worth a try.

10. Pets Finest Anti Bark Dog Collar

Pros

  • Adjustable size
  • Comfortable
  • Adheres to safety and quality standards
  • 90-day money-back guarantee

Cons

  • No off button, so battery must be manually removed and replaced to conserve it
  • May have sensitivity issues
  • Not suitable for small dogs

The Pets Finest Anti Bark Dog Collar is a shock-free collar designed to stop noisy dogs.

All its models go through rigorous quality and safety checks and meet relevant standards, with all tests conducted by independent third-party agencies.

This vibrating dog collar detects vibrations through your dog’s throat and sends a high-pitched alarming noise when it senses barking.

Additional barking will then cause the collar to respond in kind with a gentle yet effective vibration to correct the behaviour.

This device can fit neck sizes of 11 to 24 inches, meaning it is unfortunately not suitable for smaller dogs.

It’s also worth noting that this collar runs on batteries but has no off button, so you will have to take out the batteries manually if you want to conserve power. Sensitivity issues might also cause incorrect vibrations.

Still, this collar has a 90-day money-back guarantee, so there’s no harm in trying it to see if works for you.

What To Be Aware Of When Buying A Vibrating Dog Collar

Not everyone is a fan of using training methods involving vibrating dog collars. You’ve probably heard opinions on both sides before. If you’re still unsure as to which option is truly the best, consider this list of pros and cons.

Pros

Low cost for high payoff

Training a dog, especially to stop doing something as natural to them as bar, is very difficult. It’s likely that hiring a trainer is your best option, and that’s very expensive to do.

In addition, some neighbourhoods will hit you with fines if your dog is too noisy and you receive a lot of noise complaints. Most vibrating dog collars are inexpensive and well worth avoiding these fines.

You don’t have to be there

When you’re training a dog, you need to be there to correct every misstep and reward every sign of progress.

This isn’t a bad thing, but training a dog to stop barking is very different and much more difficult than training them to sit, stay, lie down or use the bathroom outside.

Many dog collars of this kind work on their own, or, at least, with a remote control. This allows you to go about your day while the training continues to be facilitated without your direct presence.

Brings results quickly

Vibrating dog collars are known for being able to help train a canine companion within a few days or weeks. This is contrary to the months you might have to spend without the collar.

Cons

Fear

Some dogs may dislike the vibration so much that they react extremely negatively to it. They may become frightened, and sometimes, this fear can lead to panic that causes incorrect training that teaches new, worse behaviours.

Discomfort

There’s no denying that, for a vibrating dog collar to work, it has to create discomfort for your dog. This can definitely be upsetting to think about, and not all dog owners want this.

Lack of positive reinforcement

The best kind of training involves positive reinforcement, such as praise or treats for good behaviour. A vibrating dog collar cannot provide that.

Conclusion

Vibrating dog collars are a great method for simple, straightforward training. They don’t hurt your dog, they deter unwanted behaviour, and it prevents the need for hours and hours of difficult training by you that just might not stick.

Remember that, much like humans, all dogs are unique and different, so you may need to try a few training options before you find one that works for you.

Know your dog, know what you need, and do your research, and it won’t be long before you have the best vibrating dog collar for your situation.

By using this website you agree to accept our Privacy Policy and Terms & Conditions